Post New Topic  
my profile | register | search | faq | forum home
    next newest topic
»  The War Diary   » General Discussions   » Current Affairs   » Gentlemen, Your verdict

UBBFriend: Email this page to someone!    
Author Topic: Gentlemen, Your verdict
Pte. Silcox
Veteran Member
Member # 94

Member Rated:

posted 07 February 2021 01:38     Profile for Pte. Silcox   Email Pte. Silcox     Send New Private Message     Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote
I read a short story called "Gentlemen Your Verdict" by an author who was a canadian artillery guy (gunner) during WW2 (apparently it was an old bar room argument according to author)

(during 1947)
Essentially it was about a submarine crew who crashed on the bottom of the sea somewhere, and they couldn't be rescued for 7 days (due to storm). There are 30 crewmembers, Only the captain knows they have air for only 2 days. Quickly and Descievely(after recontacting HQ to re-confirm rescue time) the Captain orders the 2 IC to round up the men. Once the men came, the captian told them he had good news, and he took out a bottle of licker and poured each man but 5 family men a drink. The Captain told the men he was proud of them, then toasted and all the men but the 5 who didn't drink died(very quickly) from poison.

The Captian told the 5 remaining (3 officers, 2 NCOs) of the air supply and when rescue would come. He then contacted HQ and told them the 5 men had absolutley no knowledge of what happened (killing the 25 men).

The Captian then joined the crew and killed himself via the poison

The 5 guys got questioned at the court martial
and that's how the story was told
--

Anyways, the questions are as following

- Is the Captian a murderer or a Hero?
- What gives him the right to play god
- would you kill 25 to save 5?

We had a huge discussion in English class about this and I was just wondering what your thoughts are on this.

Thanks
Travis Silcox


Posts: 46 | From: British Columbia, Canada | Registered: Nov 2000  |  IP: Logged

All times are ET  

Post New Topic   Close Topic    Move Topic      next newest topic
Hop To:

Contact Us | CdnArmy.ca | Privacy Statement

2001 CdnArmy.ca. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by Infopop Corporation
Ultimate Bulletin BoardTM 6.1.0-beta1